Pedone’s Pizza & Italian Food

Reviews

• Jim W.

  star star star star star 1 June 2026

  For a dive late-night pizza joint, what a relief of a find. It's located next to some night clubs and a brewery. This night I saw a steady flow of couples kept coming in. There is counter seating, tables and some cute couple-seats by the entrance.
  
  The young pizza chef clinched the 5th star because he explained a lot of things regarding the pizza and even bestowed us with their Mac cheese bites. My curiosity on these bites were remedied.
  
  The beer selection might not be the best, but for what's there and the price, can't beat it.
  
  The pizza was a tasty crispy slice with good amount of topping. Again, great price point.

• Sara B.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 26 May 2026

  Ugh. This place is a disaster. Living one block away, we've been here a number of times, each one worst than the last.  Last night will be my last time here. It's a shame because the food is actually pretty good.
  
  Last night's parade of horribles -- completely overwhelmed (but sweet) waitress, phone ringing off the hook, door dash/pick up orders waiting 10+ minutes while their food was sitting within eyeshot, TVs/sound not working, computer/credit card machine not working -- was kind of funny, until I realized we'd be overcharged by probably 20%.  
  
  I've literally never seen the same employee there twice. It's like every time is the single waitress/bartender/order taker's first day, because it probably is. The staff who I have interacted with have been very friendly, but the few times I've interacted with the owner, he's been disinterested and rude.
  
  I have suspicions about how such an terribly managed establishment in a prime location stays in business, but I'll keep those to myself...
  
  Luckily Paisano's is only 3 blocks away.

• Sheena P.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 15 May 2026

  Who cares about the food, when the staff is so rude? Terrible service. The girl who finally decided to take our order after finishing whatever she was doing on her personal cell phone, thew our receipt at us, and acted as if it were an issue to let us use the pen to sign the receipt.
  
  I wouldn't recommend this place to my enemy.

• Joyce T.

  star star star star star_border 11 May 2026

  Great pizza! The crust is crispy with a beautiful scale design that made crust lighter. Great young pizza chef, too.
  
  Weekdays have crazy deals on a lot of their foods. $6 for beer and 2 pizza slices. Yup.
  
  There is also Mac diamonds. Cheesy Mac gems. Moist and mouth poppin good.
  
  Bit of beer on tap.
  
  Felt like a clean pizza "dive". Open late. I enjoyed it.

• Jason C.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 8 May 2026

  This was, by far, THE WORST, takeout experience of my life. I am so disgusted that even remembering my experience now is making me angry. If you check my other reviews you will see that I'm usually very kind and almost never write something negative. Here is a summary of what happened.
  
  My wife and I ordered eggplant parmigiana and lobster ravioli. The order was supposed to take 45min. It was a Sunday night, so I figured it would be busy, so I wasn't expecting the food to be delivered on the dot or anything. Well...we get a call from the restaurant telling us that they are out of lobster--90 min later!!! To add insult to i injury, the girl over the phone had a total attitude when I couldn't think of a replacement item to order instead and even seemed annoyed and impatient with me. When we decided to order their gnocchi instead, instead of trying to compensate us for the unprofessionalism, she just told me to contact Grubhub about getting the refund for the difference in cost.
  
  Now, our food was not delivered for ANOTHER 90min. I had to call the restaurant 3 more times, each time the guy on the phone assured me the food was on the way and would arrive any moment.
  
  When the food finally got here, it was inedible. The gnocchi was not cooked. It tasted like raw dough. The eggplant was also raw. I'm pretty sure the original girl on the phone just didn't put my order in because I annoyed her, and when I called upset repeatedly they just threw my order together in a rush. Our money was pretty much wasted.
  
  I seriously would not eat there again if I had a free gift card. From their service to their product, they should be ashamed that they would treat a customer like this.